Advertisement

Science Friday
Signature of antimatter detected in lightning
Fermi telescope finds evidence that positrons, not just electrons, are in storms on Earth
font_down font_up Text Size
access
Antimatter lightningDuring two recent lightning storms, the Fermi telescope found evidence that positrons, not just electrons, are in storms on Earth.Axel Rouvin/Flickr

WASHINGTON — Designed to scan the heavens thousands to billions of light-years beyond the solar system for gamma rays, the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope has also picked up a shocking vibe from Earth. During its first 14 months of operation, the flying observatory has detected 17 gamma-ray flashes associated with terrestrial storms — and some of those flashes have contained a surprising signature of antimatter.

During two recent lightning storms, Fermi recorded gamma-ray emissions of a particular energy that could have been produced only by the decay of energetic positrons, the antimatter equivalent of electrons. The observations are the first of their kind for lightning storms. Michael Briggs of the University of Alabama in Huntsville announced the puzzling findings November 5 at the 2009 Fermi Symposium.

It’s a surprise to have found the signature of positrons during a lightning storm, Briggs said.

The 17 flashes Fermi detected occurred just before, during and immediately after lightning strikes, as tracked by the World Wide Lightning Location Network.

During lightning storms previously observed by other spacecraft, energetic electrons moving toward the craft slowed down and produced gamma rays. The unusual positron signature seen by Fermi suggests that the normal orientation for an electric field associated with a lightning storm somehow reversed, Briggs said. Modelers are now working to figure out how the field reversal could have occurred. But for now, he said, the answer is up in the air.

Recording gamma-ray flashes — which have the potential to harm airplanes in storms — isn’t new. The first were found by NASA’s Compton Gamma-ray Observatory in the early 1990s. NASA’s RHESSI satellite, which primarily looks at X-ray and gamma-ray emissions from the sun, has found some 800 terrestrial gamma-ray flashes, Briggs noted.


Found in: Atom & Cosmos
Comments 16
  • Interesting twist for this story. I remember reading a few papers on terrestrial gamma ray flashes detected by Compton in the 90's, as mentioned in the article. I guess positronic lightning isn't all that unexpected, but the mechanism for generation should prove interesting.
    Jon Hanford Jon Hanford
    Nov. 7, 2009 at 10:50am
  • This could explain Sprites, Blue Jets, Elves, etc.
    Charles Lassiter Charles Lassiter
    Nov. 7, 2009 at 1:22pm
  • Possibly the same thing is happening before or just after lightning strokes as happens in a Farnsworth-Hirsch fusor or posibly something like a Polywell. A relevant experiment would be to look for neutrons and helium atoms near lightning events that also have positron signatures.
    Joe Sleator Joe Sleator
    Nov. 8, 2009 at 5:42pm
  • Could it be that some lightning is triggered by a cosmic ray, creating an ionized path, much like in a Muller tube in a Geiger Counter? So the antimatter could be related to the trigger of the lightning, rather than caused by the lightning.
    KentD KentD
    Nov. 8, 2009 at 9:00pm
  • I have a special relationship with lightning . I dont understand why or how I have managed to be hit 4 times and survive. I can tell you this , it physically felt different twice . I cant explain it but I can tell you that the air is crisp , clean and antiseptic moments after a strike and you are either very , very hot ,, or immediately cold just before a strike . Each strike is very different so to put them all in one category would be wrong . Id love to know more about Lightning so please share your thoughts :)
    Mark  Stinson Mark Stinson
    Nov. 8, 2009 at 11:44pm
  • During the lightning stroke, ionized nitrogen and oxygen are accelerated to high energy and collide to produce nuclear reactions that produce carbon-11 and nitrogen-13. These nuclides decay by positron emission. When the positron annihilates with an electron, 511-keV gamma rays are produced. I believe that this effect has been observed before, but I don't recall the reference.
    Keith Marlow
    Keith Marlow Keith Marlow
    Nov. 9, 2009 at 11:05am
  • Energy released in a lightening bolt produces proton-rich nuclei that decay by positron (anti-electron, e+) emission: [Link was removed]

    Positrons (e+) annihilate and emit characteristic 0.511 MeV gamma rays.

    Proton-rich nuclei are easy to produce with an electrical discharge through Hydrogen, the lightest of all elements. Lightweight elements like H are enriched in the upper atmosphere of the Earth and the Sun.

    An electrical discharge through the Sun's H-rich atmosphere was recently found to produce two positron-emitters there, N-13 and O-15 ["Observational confirmation of the Sun's CNO cycle," Journal of Fusion Energy 25 (October 20, 2006) pages 141-144] [Link was removed]

    The top of Earth's atmosphere also contains copious amounts of the most lightweight element, H. That is probably where proton-rich nuclei are produced by electrical discharges in air here on Earth.

    With kind regards,
    Oliver K. Manuel
    Oliver K. Manuel Oliver K. Manuel
    Nov. 9, 2009 at 11:26am
  • Fermi telescope finds evidence that positrons,
    not just electrons, are in storms on Earth
    ==== .
    So the antimatter could be related to the trigger of the lightning,
    rather than caused by the lightning.
    ================= .
    #
    You know, it would be sufficient to really understand the electron.
    / Albert Einstein./
    #
    Tell me what an electron is and I'll then tell you everything.
    / Somebody./
    #
    " The electron that can be told is not the true electron."
    / David Harrison /
    #
    One professor asked a student:
    “ What is an electron?”
    “ Ah, God damn it! I have forgotten. And in fact even in the
    morning I knew it. ”- the student answered.
    “ You should recollect it without fail, - professor said –
    because you were the unique person who knew, what
    electron was, and you had suddenly forgotten!”
    / From a book. /
    This old joke does not grow old.
    We don’t know what electron is, what positron is, but . . .
    === .
    Strange physic’s contradiction
    1
    On the one hand :
    The particles in the Universe are more than antiparticles
    / Baryon asymmetry /
    2.
    On the other hand:
    Dark matter in the Universe is more than visual matter

    Question :
    Does one physic’s hand know that the other hand do ?

    Sadovnik Socratus
    israel socratus israel socratus
    Nov. 13, 2009 at 6:47am
  • hmmm... there is "field reversal" of sorts that typically occurs as a very long and loud positively charged lightning strike that takes place near the end of the life of a t-storm and originates in the top of the cloud after the bottom of the storm has discharged most of its negative charge.
    Rick Ryals Rick Ryals
    Nov. 13, 2009 at 4:09pm
  • This is NOT as much of a surpirse to me as it might be to some; but then the first thing I thought of was 'Red Genies' & 'Blue Jets' - both of which are upward propagating types of lightning (shooting up from the tops of cells), and the latter of which has been spectrally disected to reveal that the Photons were created by a multi-million degree plasma.
    There are more wonders (yet to be discovered) under the sun and stars than all of our science........
    James Staples James Staples
    Nov. 14, 2009 at 5:21pm
  • Hmmmmmm....Rick Ryals, I do believe that your on to something!
    James Staples James Staples
    Nov. 14, 2009 at 5:22pm
  • Accelerated electron form can change its charge and become a positron form, like in atom probably.

    It is one of electropositron hipothesis predict.
    Enes Enes Enes Enes
    Nov. 24, 2009 at 12:28pm

  • [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    m9bnat m9bnat m9bnat m9bnat
    Jan. 3, 2010 at 10:12pm

  • [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    m9bnat m9bnat m9bnat m9bnat
    Jan. 5, 2010 at 7:20pm
  • Thank you administrator...
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    [Link was removed]
    Science News Science News
    Jan. 14, 2010 at 8:15pm
  • that is it
    [Link was removed]
    para kazan para kazan
    Jan. 18, 2010 at 12:40am
Post a comment (Please note: All links will be removed from comments.)

Please login or register to participate.


Advertisement
Citations & References:
seperator
  • Briggs, M. 2009. Fermi-GBM observations of terrestrial gamma-ray flashes. Fermi Symposium. Nov. 5. Washington, D.C. [Go to]
Reader Favorites:
seperator
SN on the Web:
seperator