- :: Atom & Cosmos
- :: Body & Brain
- :: Earth
- :: Environment
- :: Genes & Cells
- :: Humans
- :: Life
- :: Matter & Energy
- :: Molecules
- :: Science & Society
- :: Other Topics
- :: Science News For Kids
http://www.sciencenews.org/view/generic/id/42475
Chimps ambidextrous when digging wells
Measurements of water holes dug in the wild suggest that these apes don’t have right versus left preference
April 25th, 2009; Vol.175 #9 (p. 9)
CHICAGO — Give the chimpanzees living at Uganda’s Toro-Semliki Wildlife Reserve a hand for having the mental moxie to dig water-collection holes along the edge of a river that flows only during rainy months. In fact, give them two hands, because wells dug by these chimps show no evidence of having been fashioned by either right-handers or left-handers, according to anthropologist Linda Marchant of Miami University in Oxford, Ohio.
Evidence of ambidexterity in Semliki chimps counters a suggestion from other researchers, based largely on studies of captive animals, that chimps often favor one hand over the other when performing various tasks. If it exists, chimp handedness interests researchers because it may reflect an evolutionary move toward a brain organized more like that of people — with one hemisphere dominating over the other and prompting either right- or left-handedness —than has often been assumed.
“We see no signs of handedness among the Semliki chimps, which appears to be the condition in the wild,” said anthropologist and study coauthor William McGrew of the University of Cambridge in England.
Marchant presented her team’s new findings on April 3 at the American Association of Physical Anthropologists annual meeting.
Rather than excluding hand preferences altogether among wild chimps, findings at Semliki indicate that chimps use both hands equally on physically demanding jobs, such as well digging, remarked Elizabeth Lonsdorf, director of the Lester E. Fisher Center for the Study and Conservation of Apes at Lincoln Park Zoo in Chicago.
“I suspect that for activities requiring fine movements, such as termite fishing, chimps’ hand preferences will pop out on closer study,” Lonsdorf said.
Earlier work at Gombe National Park in Tanzania found that wild chimps living there tended to use their left hands when engaging in a practice known as termite fishing, she noted. In this activity, chimps poke sticks or grass blades into termite mounds and then put the insect-covered implements into their mouths for a protein-rich snack.
Digging wells at Semliki takes far more effort than collecting termites at Gombe. Chimps scoop out holes in sandy riverbeds, a process that leaves two piles of soil on opposite sides of each depression. During rainy times of the year, river water fills the holes, from which chimps drink either by mouth or by dipping and then sucking on absorbent wads of leaves.
Over two days during the dry season in 2006, Marchant’s group counted 91 chimp-dug wells along Semliki’s main river. Initial observations of the holes indicated that they had been dug by individuals using both hands.
A six-month study, conducted from May to November 2008, confirmed that finding, Marchant said. That period included both wet and dry seasons.
Researchers walked for more than 5 kilometers along the same river and identified 121 wells. A series of measurements determined that each hole was symmetrical and likely produced by two hands acting in concert. Each of the two soil mounds adjacent to any particular well weighed the same.
Wells were dug in both dry and wet seasons. Chimps didn’t dig more wells at rainy times because water continually flowed in the river in 2008, Marchant said.
Chimps dug shallower wells last year than in 2006, apparently because of heavier rainfall in 2008.
So far, Marchant and her colleagues have not directly observed any Semliki chimps in the act of digging wells.
Marchant had assumed that only Semliki chimps created water holes by rivers. But in another meeting presentation the same day, a team led by Jill Pruetz of Iowa State University in Ames reported that chimps living in an area of southeastern Senegal called Fongoli also scoop out makeshift wells on river banks.
Found in: Anthropology, Life and Zoology
Advertisement
Suggested Reading:
Citations & References:
- L.F. MARCHANT, W.C. MCGREW, C.L.R. PAYNE, T.H. WEBSTER, K.D. HUNT. 2009. Well-digging by Semliki chimpanzees: New Data. (abstract), presented in Primatology: Primate brain, cognition, growth, learning, and reproductive biology, The 78th Annual Meeting of the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, Chicago, March 31-April 4. Program available [Go to]
Reader Favorites:
- Sun may not be a 'Goldilocks' star
- Moon crash reveals crater held water
- Plastics ingredients could make a boy's play less masculine
- B vitamin outperforms another drug in keeping arteries clear
- Mummies reveal heart disease plagued ancient Egyptians
SN on the Web:
Site originally developed by Confluent Forms LLC, some elements © 2001 - 2009


On the other hand (no pun intended) as primates evolve towards ground and manual dexterity becomes an advantage assigning more processing power to one hand can become useful without causing unfortunate accidents.
It might be usefull to make a comperative study across the primates as well as hominids (if skeletal data about handiness can be retrived from finds), correlated to the percentage of time spent on trees/foraging/tool handling etc.
A. "Chimps ambidextrous when digging wells"
http://www.sciencenews.org/view/generic/id/42475/title/Chimps_ambidextrous_when_digging_wells
A survey of water-collection holes dug on the banks of an African river by wild chimpanzees indicates that, unlike people, these apes don’t have a preference for using either the right or left hand on manual tasks.
B. Human dexterity preference became genetic by compulsions of changing human culture
"Human brain contralaterallization"
http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-P81pQcU1dLBbHgtjQjxG_Q--?cq=1&p=153
A note I e-mailed July 18, 2005 to C Walsh, Harvard, re his "Asymmetry in Human Left/Right Cerebral Cortex", Science, Vol 308, Issue 5729, 1794-1798, 17 June 2005.
A) You write: "The human left and right cerebral hemispheres are anatomically and functionally asymmetric. To test whether human cortical asymmetry has a molecular basis, we studied gene expression levels between the left and right embryonic hemispheres using serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE). We identified and verified 27 differentially expressed genes, which suggests that human cortical asymmetry is accompanied by early, marked transcriptional asymmetries.
B) The expression "asymmetry has a molecular basis" sounds strange. The aspects of the asymmetry include, of course, ALSO genes' expressions, the total asymmetry being the product of specific evolution of the human cerebral cortex.
C) In July 1997 I wrote the following "conjectural scenario":
" Humans' uniqueness on Earth was initiated by a stimulus in a zone in the brain of some of them when challenged by needs for new manipulations, and for new capabilities of analysis and assessments of wider vistas open to them when changing posture to erect due to change of environment from forests to plains. The new demands employed existing brain cells in one half of their brain, overtaxed its capabilities and led to compensation by overworking the symmetrically located cells in the second half of the split brain and this in turn led again to compensation in the first half thus causing contralaterallization that is still evolving now".
D) I suggest that the probability of a similar asymmetry might be sought in ocean mammals, having undergone a radical intensive change of living circumstance and mode, like our ancestral primates.
Respectfully,
DH
Dov Henis
(Comments From The 22nd Century)
Life's Manifest
http://www.the-scientist.com/community/posts/list/112.page#578
EVOLUTION Beyond Darwin 200
http://www.physforum.com/index.php?showtopic=14988&st=405entry396201
http://www.the-scientist.com/community/posts/list/100/122.page#1407
Please login or register to participate.